If your sales strategy isn’t working, the plan on paper may not be the problem. More often, the weak point is how the plan is carried out: who you contact, what you say and what you do after the first message goes unanswered.
You have a target list. Your pitch is ready. You have sent emails, made calls and followed up. Yet replies are slow, prospects say they will “get back to you” and never do, and proposals disappear without a word. If you run a startup or a small business in Nigeria or elsewhere in Africa, or you handle business development for one, you will know how discouraging this feels.
I work in business development at Evaluate Media, where I reach out to businesses in real estate, construction, legal services and education. I have had the unanswered calls and the proposals that went nowhere, and I have also had the replies that made the effort worthwhile. Over time I have noticed that the same seven mistakes keep appearing, in my own outreach and in the businesses I speak to across Africa.
In short, most sales strategies fail in execution, not in design. The seven common causes are leading with your services instead of the prospect’s problem, contacting the wrong person, weak follow-ups, using one pitch for every business, chasing the sale before earning trust, ignoring why prospects say no, and not tracking what works. Even when your outreach is right, a weak online presence can still lose deals your pitch has won.
1. You sell what you do instead of solving what they need
Think of the last sales message you received. Was it about how long the company has been in business and the long list of things it offers?
Many sales conversations start this way: “We are a full-service agency offering media, PR, social media management and web development…”
There is nothing wrong with introducing your company. The problem is that prospects care more about their own challenges than about your service list. A property developer in Lekki wants to know why a finished estate is not attracting buyers. A law firm in Abuja wants more of the right clients in a crowded market. Those are the conversations worth starting.
Before you contact a business, ask one question: What problem is this business likely facing, and how could what I offer help? If you cannot answer, you need to do more research first. Open with the problem, then explain how you can help.
2. You contact the wrong person
A well-written message that reaches the wrong person goes nowhere. Emails sent to info@ or sales@ addresses are often read by someone with no power to decide, or lost among general enquiries.
This matters more than most people realise, because business purchases rarely rest on one person. Gartner’s research on business buying found that a typical purchase of a complex solution involves six to ten decision makers. For a small business buying marketing or sales support, the group is smaller, but there is still usually one person who holds the budget and another who has a say in the choice.
Find out who is responsible for the decision. Depending on the company, that could be the Managing Director, the Head of Marketing or the Business Development Manager. Use LinkedIn, the company website and your own network to find them. In many African markets, a phone call or a WhatsApp message to the right person can also work better than a cold email, so do not rely on email alone.
3. Your follow-ups give prospects no reason to reply
I am guilty of this one too. “Just following up on my previous email” is probably the most common line in sales email, and it gives the reader nothing new.
Following up is still essential. A good share of replies only come after the second or third message, so stopping after one email leaves opportunities behind. But a long run of identical reminders does more harm than good, and can push your messages into spam. Follow up with purpose, not pressure.
Make every follow-up add something. Mention something recent about the prospect’s business, such as a new project or announcement. Point out one specific improvement they could make to their website or social media pages. Or share a short idea that could help them, even if they are not ready to buy.
Change the channel too. If three emails have had no reply, try a short phone call or a LinkedIn message instead of sending a fourth email.
4. You use the same pitch for every business
A real estate company in Lekki, a law firm in Victoria Island and a private school in Ibadan may all need marketing support, but they do not operate in the same way. Their customers, challenges and reasons for choosing a provider are different. So why send them the same pitch?
Generic messages are easy to spot and easy to ignore. A message that names the prospect’s business and gives a specific reason for writing is far more likely to be read and answered.
A short research routine makes a big difference. Before you pitch, read through the company’s website and social media pages, search for its name online to see what the press has said about it, and note what it has done recently and how it presents itself to customers.
You may find a website that needs updating, social media pages that are barely used, or a strong track record with almost no media coverage. Each of these gives you something specific to say, and it shows the prospect you took the time to understand their business.
5. You care more about closing than about building trust
The goal of sales is revenue, and nobody pretends otherwise. But not every prospect is ready to buy when you first reach them. Some are still comparing options. Some have the need but not the budget. Others need more time to decide whether they can trust you.
Instead of pushing for a yes at every point, stay useful. Share an idea, offer an honest observation or answer a question openly. If a prospect does not need your service yet, say so. People remember the salesperson who understood their business and helped, not the one who kept asking when they would sign. In the long run, that reputation brings more business than persistence alone.
6. You do not find out why prospects say no
When a prospect declines, most salespeople move on to the next lead. Keeping the pipeline moving is sensible, but you may be missing useful information.
Where it is appropriate, ask: Was it the price? Is it not a priority right now? Are they already working with another provider? Did the proposal miss what they needed? You will not always get an answer, but when you do, write it down.
Over time, these answers reveal patterns. You may find that the objection you feared most is rare, and that something you never considered comes up again and again. That is information no training course can give you, because it comes from your own market.
7. You do not track what is working
This is the mistake that quietly sits behind all the others. Without a simple record of your outreach, you cannot tell which messages, industries or channels are producing results.
You do not need expensive software to begin. A spreadsheet or a basic CRM (customer relationship management tool, which is simply a system for recording your contacts and conversations) is enough. For each prospect, record the company, the decision maker’s name and role, the date and channel of each contact, the stage they have reached and the reason for any “no” or delay. The stages can be as simple as first contact, replied, meeting held, proposal sent, won or lost.
Also check each lead against four simple questions, often called BANT, which stands for budget, authority, need and timing. Do they have the budget? Is the person speaking to you able to make the decision? Is there a real need? Is the timing right? Leads that fail these checks are not worthless, but they belong on a longer-term follow-up list, not in your daily push.
Review your numbers weekly. Look at how many messages produced replies, how many replies became meetings and how many meetings became proposals. The step where most prospects drop away is the part of your strategy that needs attention first.
Why your online presence can lose deals your pitch has won
Even when your outreach is right, most prospects run one more test before they reply. They search for your business online.
After a good call or a strong proposal, a prospect will usually check your website, look through your social media pages and search for reviews, media coverage or examples of your work. Many will also ask someone in their network whether they have heard of you. If they find very little, or what they find does not match the quality you promised, the confidence you built in the pitch can quickly fade.
At Evaluate Media, we often meet businesses with excellent products and services whose online presence tells a much weaker story. Their work speaks for itself offline, but a prospect who looks them up does not get to see it. An outdated website, inactive social media pages or no press coverage can quietly undo the work of a good sales team.
Sales and marketing are not separate jobs. Your outreach opens the door, but your website, media features, social media presence and client testimonials are what the prospect sees when deciding whether to walk through it. Before you send your next proposal, search for your own business the way a prospect would, and ask whether what you find would convince you.
A simple weekly routine to fix your sales outreach
You may not need a new sales strategy. You may only need to run your current one more carefully. Start the week by building a short list of well-researched prospects and finding the right decision maker for each. From Tuesday to Thursday, send personalised messages that open with the prospect’s likely challenge, and follow up earlier contacts with something new each time. On Friday, update your records, note every objection you heard and decide what to change for the following week.
A smaller list of well-qualified prospects, contacted thoughtfully, will usually beat a large list contacted carelessly.
Frequently asked questions about sales strategy and outreach
Why is my sales outreach not getting replies?
The usual causes are a message that talks about your company instead of the prospect’s problem, a message sent to someone who cannot decide, and follow-ups that add nothing new. Fix targeting and relevance first, then look at volume.
How many times should I follow up with a prospect?
There is no single number that suits every business, but experience shows that a small number of well-spaced, useful follow-ups works better than a long run of identical reminders. If email gets no answer after three attempts, switch to another channel such as a phone call or LinkedIn.
How do I find the right decision maker in a company?
Start with the company website and LinkedIn to identify the Managing Director, Head of Marketing or equivalent. Ask your network for an introduction where you can, and call the company to confirm who handles the decision you are trying to influence.
How can a small business in Nigeria improve its sales strategy without a big budget?
Improve targeting, research each prospect before you contact them, write follow-ups that add value, and keep a simple record of results in a spreadsheet. These steps cost time, not money.
How can I get more clients for my business in Nigeria?
Start with a short list of businesses that genuinely need what you offer, and reach the person who makes the decision by email, phone, LinkedIn or WhatsApp. Make every message about their challenge, follow up with something useful, and make sure your website and social media pages give them a reason to trust you when they look you up.
The bottom line
Sales is not about making more calls, sending more emails or following up until someone gives in. It is about understanding the people you want to reach, knowing what matters to their business and showing clearly how you can help. Sometimes the best thing you can do for your sales results is to stop talking for a moment and listen more closely to the person in front of you.
At Evaluate Media, we work with businesses in real estate, construction, legal services, education and other sectors, helping them build visibility and connect with the right audiences through media, public relations, social media management and web development.
About the author
Esther Olufowora is the Business Development Associate and Client Experience Officer at Evaluate Media, a media, PR, social media management and web development agency serving clients in real estate, construction, legal, education and beyond. She works on the front line of how businesses win trust and new clients, from identifying the right decision makers to shaping outreach that speaks to their real challenges.
Sources
Gartner, The New B2B Buying Journey, on the size of business buying groups for complex purchases.

